« Why We Play Music, Part Two | Main | Do I Need To Master My Recordings? And What Is Mastering, Anyway? »

Why Are You Making Music?


Save to
del.icio.us

Last night I was watching an episode of South Park. The one where Stan and Kyle have a rock band called Moop and they get busted for downloading music for free and start a protest to not play music until the free downloading stops. All the stars join them. Meanwhile Cartman decides to start a Christian rock band and make an album that goes platinum. When he is confronted with the fact that he knows nothing about Christianity he replies, “I know enough to exploit them.” Very funny irreverent stuff, but as South Park always does, it got me to thinking about why I am in this business.   And it’s question that I offer to you all today, which happens to be the day of my one hundredth post, so I am feeling pensive and full of questions of self examination. Valuable if it only happens once in a while.  But back to the question.

Why are you in the business of making music? And why are you still doing it?JamesLeeMA12129461-0001.jpg

For me, I think part of it is simply the line of least resistance. I come from a very musical family. Music was always a part of every gathering and, as an aside, my grandfather was an extremely funny man, who did a lot of comedy and even allegedly sold a very famous comedic bit to some famous comics at the end of the depression. My grandfather and my uncle taught me hundreds of the old songs on a ukulele because I was too little to hold a guitar. The point being that it was easy to go that way. Family, circumstance and a natural inherited gift for music and comedy suggested I should go that way.

There was also the enormous attention I got from girls when I first started playing out. At fourteen Karen Edwards had my heart and all my waking thoughts, tho she never knew. And her love of the Kingston Trio and folk music, got me into the acoustic guitar world from which I still derive enormous satisfaction lo, these forty nine years later.

When I first started playing out there were only a few musicians who were actually rich from doing music. Frank Sinatra and Elvis Presley come to mind. But most musicians did not get into the business of making music to get rich when I started. We simply loved playing music and seemed to be good at it. The money and the girls that followed further stoked the fire.

Then there was the Beatles. They not only got incomprehensively rich doing this, but they fired the musical core of a generation of people. I don’t think in the history of the world, there have been so very many good musicians. There are guitar players in bar bands right now that in 1961 would have appeared as guitar heroes. Now do you have to do something else besides being good to be noticed. I’d say yes, tho there are plenty examples of people that are moderately gifted who soar to the top of the heap for a minute.

All these thoughts come at you all the time when you are playing and continuing to follow your muse. An inner dialogue of discouragement and negativity that we all must contend with and continue. I find that while that dialogue is going on, I just keep on doing what I was going to do anyway and eventually the dialogue stops. I try to ignore the discouraging aspects of being where I am in life and career and continue to aspire.

So why am I still doing it? There are a couple of reasons that jump out at me. The first being that I’ve been doing this my whole life and I’ve never been better than I am right now. How could I stop now that I am getting so good? And secondly, musicians are famous for following the carrot. I keep thinking that if I keep at it I’ll get to be as good as I know I can be, while cognizant of the fact that the better you get, the more better you need to get to satisfy some kind of longing to get to the place where music just pours out of you unencumbered. And it’s always someplace else from where you are. What’s the phrase? Everytime I think I’m on top of it all—they move it. Some people, like Corky Siegel for instance, (www.chamberblues.com) never seem to practice and are unbelieveably musical. For myself, I know that if I play for an hour or so, the musicality that is inside of me finds its way out. So that’s two reasons.

And thirdly, after all these years of performing and composing and recording, I really don’t want to do anything else more than I want to do this. I have lots of interests but this is what I always opt for whenever the chance for a choice comes up. Can I make a living at it for my whole life? I’ll have to get back to you on that one. Right now, at sixty one, I would say definitely yes.

So ask yourself why you are doing this and why do you continue in the face of diminishing financial reward and fierce competition for recognition. With the internet and computer programs everyone can sound like they are musical whizzes, so the competition appears more daunting than ever. And yet, here you are still writing, still looking for gigs and still recording.

What I know is that following your bliss is more rewarding than making a bunch of money at something you absolutely hate doing. I don’t feel that I’ve wasted my life or that I could have been more successful at something else. I love what I do and I love trying to get better at it and I love it that at my stage of life I still have so much passion for what I do and I love how vibrant and alive it keeps me.

Maybe I’ve answered my own question. So tell me, why are you still doing this?

Posted on Friday, January 25, 2008 at 09:03AM by Registered Commenterjames lee stanley in | Comments5 Comments | References7 References
Share this: Digg | Add to sk*rt | Reddit | Stumble Upon | del.icio.us

EmailEmail Article to Friend

References (7)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Response: MUSICAL INSTRUMENT
  • Response
    Response: acoustic guitar
  • Response
  • Response
    Response: bar code
    bar code public repository.
  • Response
    Response: Elvis
  • Response
    Response: fire place
  • Response
    Response: vintage comics
    Informative vintage comics website.

Reader Comments (5)

James Lee—A very good, introspective, and personal post indeed! For me, it’s simply an addiction. I used to get pretty frustrated in Hawaii when my quest for a solo career kept getting detoured with gigs as a sideman--much less, not on my primary instrument. Why am I spending time making other people sound good? I never wanted to be a sideman, however the opportunities were abundant and the phone kept ringing. Then I realized that these people heard something that I was doing that they felt would enhance their sound. And, how could I possible turn down C&K? I realized that I’m doing this because I am hopelessly addicted to making music in any capacity. The bottom line is that once it’s is in your blood there is no escape from being a prisoner of the muse. And, as you mentioned, loving what you do is important and the catalyst that makes the addiction whole. If making music is the reason you wake up each morning, then play on and never stop. The more you play, the better you feel and the stronger you are in both body and mind. In essence, free-lance human beings follow the path of heart rather than the path of convenience. I’ll get there yet.
Take care,
Max

January 25, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterMax

James, how right you are about following your bliss. In my humble opinion there are few things worse or more soul-numbing on an everyday level than having to spend your time working at something you hate,

I'm just so glad your bliss is something we all can share and enjoy.

Eva

January 26, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterEva

Hi James,

I would hate to live in a world without music or art for that matter. People like you who have the gift of a great voice make life better for all of us with your beautiful music. It's just taking what God gave you and making the world a better place for others. I think too much emphasis is put on the financial aspects of life and not enough on enjoying our time on this planet.

Diane

January 28, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterDiane Archambault

eva, max and diane,
thank you for your posts. encouraging and enriching thoughts from all of you, not to mention the compliments, something we all never get enough of.

January 31, 2008 | Registered Commenterjames lee stanley

It's intermittent breathing isnt it...

February 9, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterBobby Brogan

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>